First, the clear answer is no. The answer to how the state ranks, however, depends a lot on methodology. The Tax Foundation has a robust method for answering this question and arrives at the conclusion that Illinois is not even in the top five. Notably, New York tops the list with a 15.9 percent rate, followed by Connecticut, Hawaii, Vermont, California, and New Jersey. All of these before Illinois appears.
The reason methodology matters is because different states have different tax regimes. The Tax Foundation considers the three main tax types — individual income, sales tax, and corporate income tax — for its ranking of tax competitiveness. Washington state, for example, has no income tax but taxes on services tend to be much higher than in Illinois. Montana has no sales tax but it has a progressive income tax. Illinois has by constitutional provision a flat income tax. Still Illinois doesn’t rank at the top of the high tax list but in fact toward the middle. Again, methodology matters. The Tax Payers Federation of Illinois has a different result from Charles Schwab. The Civic Federation discusses methodology and advises that “When policymakers and commentators cite these rankings as justification for tax policy changes, it is important that they specify which ranking method they are using and acknowledge that the most recent rankings available are from a year when Illinois taxes were substantially higher than they are now.” It is worth noting also that according to a study at the Paul Simon Institute at SIU, public revenues are spent disproportionately in the southern parts of the state contrary to the belief that the Chicago area receives all of the attention from Springfield.
A 2026 study by the Illinois Department of Revenue analyzed the state’s property tax and it agreed with tax critics that there is a need for changes. In 2020, Illinois voters rejected a constitutional amendment that would have changed the flat income tax, a measure that would opened the door to shifting the burden from property taxes. Regardless of all of this, Illinois has become a $1 trillion economy. If it was its own country Illinois would be among the G20. This is a sign of health regardless of the debates over tax policy.
For an excellent look at the early history of American taxation and the legacies of progressive and regressive taxation consider reading Robin L. Einhorn’s American Taxation, American Slavery (University of Chicago Press, 2006).
